Oklahoma Limits Claims for Construction Cases
July 29, 2025 —
Lian Skaf - The Subrogation StrategistOften times, subrogation practitioners take the “kitchen sink” approach when pursuing claims: they name all potentially liable parties under all available legal theories and whittle down from there. With construction defect cases in particular, the difficulty of identifying exactly who did what and which contractual provisions have which effect can lead to the decision to throw everything against the wall and see what sticks. However, in some cases, dealing with the ensuing motion practice from that approach just is not worth it.
In Proe, et. al. v. Diamond Homes et. al., 2025 OK Civ. App. 18, the Court of Appeals of Oklahoma (Appellate Court) took a restrictive approach when analyzing the plaintiffs’ various claims. In limiting both who the plaintiffs could sue and under which theories, it reigned in the plaintiffs’ ability to cast a wide net.
The plaintiffs (collectively, the Proes) originally sued the defendants based on a dispute over the construction of their residential home. In July of 2017, Diamond Homes, through Mike Emery, entered into a construction contract with the Proes to build a new home. Despite issues with the home’s foundation, the Proes moved into the home on July 5, 2018. They then began correcting the defects.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Lian Skaf, White and Williams LLPMr. Skaf may be contacted at
skafl@whiteandwilliams.com